The Internet criticism of ABA as an autism intervention comes largely from a rejection of evidence based medicine, ideological based rigidity and lack of any real experience with ABA. To the anti-behaviorists no ABA supportive studies are acceptable unless they are double blind controlled studies conducted over the life time of autistic persons. Obviously it would be unethical to provide a placebo intervention to an autistic child as an intervention over a lengthy period of time.
The various studies described by the American Academy of Pediatrics, the US Surgeon General, state agencies in New York, California and Maine, the Association for Science in Autism Treatment, the Center for Autism and Related Disorders, the May Institute and the thousands of health care and education professionals who actually work with and help autistic children will be ignored by the anti-ABA ideologues. There is no need to mention of course that the direct observations of autistic children by their own parents who live with their children, care for them, help them and observe them 24/7 are of no weight whatsoever to the ideologues for whom NO information supportive of ABA could ever be acceptable.
Some of the anti-ABA rhetoric originates with adult persons with various autism spectrum disorders who themselves have had no actual involvement with ABA. The further removed from the realities of ABA and the need for an effective intervention that helps autistic children the greater the chance that the irrational anti-ABA ideology will take root. The criticisms themselves are largely non-evidence based and ignore the many positive contributions that ABA has made to the lives of autistic children including my severely autistic son Conor.
Conor has learned various skills, reduced self injurious behavior, increased communication skills, attended a neighborhood school and functioned well. On the sidebar of this blog are pictures of Conor holding his perfect attendance certificate from grade 6 during which time he received ABA instruction at school. This year colds and a flu prevented him from perfect attendance but his desire to attend school did not diminish. He loves school ABA and all. Why would Conor jump up each day eager to attend school where he receives ABA intervention if it was so abusive?
I post many picture sets of Conor on this blog site over the past 3 years. These portray him as what he is -- a very happy, personable and lovable boy. ABA has not turned him "robotic" or robbed him of his personality. There is nothing at all abusive about ABA for autistic children, certainly not for Conor, despite the absurd rhetoric of the anti-behaviorists.
Conor is now 13 1/2 years old and stands 5' 11''. In the past year and a half he has undergone the adolescent "change of life" with rapid growth spurts and all the other changes that can be so disruptive of young personalities in the teen years. While there are some challenging behaviors at times there is nothing out of the ordinary. Despite his growing size, strength and disruptive adolescent changes he is still a very well behaved, gentle young man. We have not felt the need to provide Conor with ANY medications at any time to manage his behavior.
Although he used to bite himself with some frequency, and still does on occasion, such self harmful behavior is rare. He does not return home at the end of a day at school and engage in self injury as a way of coping psychologically as one prominent anti-ABA activist testified that she would do at the end of the work day. The ideologues can blame ABA intervention for Conor's near elimination of self injurious behavior or they can pretend that my direct observations about the impact of ABA in reducing such behavior are of no weight. No need to guess which way the anti-behaviorists would lean on that choice.
Although he used to bite himself with some frequency, and still does on occasion, such self harmful behavior is rare. He does not return home at the end of a day at school and engage in self injury as a way of coping psychologically as one prominent anti-ABA activist testified that she would do at the end of the work day. The ideologues can blame ABA intervention for Conor's near elimination of self injurious behavior or they can pretend that my direct observations about the impact of ABA in reducing such behavior are of no weight. No need to guess which way the anti-behaviorists would lean on that choice.
Conor has received NONE of the medications prescribed for many autistic children. The anti-ABA ideologues can also blame ABA for that result but they won't. They don't really want to look at the issue objectively. They do not want to look at the whole picture including the benefits ABA has brought to my son or other autistic children.
If you are the parent of a newly diagnosed autistic child consult your attending health care professionals about the best way to help your child. Make any treatment or intervention decisions with their input but do not be turned off of ABA as a possible intervention to help your child by the anti-ABA rhetoric that permeates some Internet autism hubs. Most of such rhetoric emanates from people with no direct involvement in helping autistic children. Most of such rhetoric emanates from people with no actual experience with ABA. Most of such rhetoric emanates from people, whether they fancy themselves researchers or not, who just don't know what they are talking about when they are talking about ABA. Do not be misled by the misbehavior of the anti-behaviorists.
In the meantime I am looking forward to another day with my wonderful son who has benefited greatly from his ABA intervention. Conor will probably also enjoy the day ... without the need to injure himself so that he can "cope psychologically" ... and without medication.
God damn that ABA!
In the meantime I am looking forward to another day with my wonderful son who has benefited greatly from his ABA intervention. Conor will probably also enjoy the day ... without the need to injure himself so that he can "cope psychologically" ... and without medication.
God damn that ABA!
autism
0 التعليقات:
إرسال تعليق