Recent Movies
‏إظهار الرسائل ذات التسميات Autism Canada. إظهار كافة الرسائل
‏إظهار الرسائل ذات التسميات Autism Canada. إظهار كافة الرسائل

On World Autism Awareness Day Canadian Government Damned Itself With Faint Praise

Damn With Faint Praise

Compliment so feebly that it amounts to no compliment at all, or even implies condemnation. 

For example, The reviewer damned the singer with faint praise, admiring her dress but not mentioning her voice. This idea was already expressed in Roman times by Favorinus (c. a.d. 110) but the actual expression comes from Alexander Pope's Epistle to Doctor Arbuthnot (1733): "Damn with faint praise, assent with civil leer, and, without sneering, teach the rest to sneer."

 Answers.com


The Government of Canada, with its World Autism Awareness Day message from the Honourable Leona Aglukkaq, Minister of Health,  damned itself with faint praise for its feeble efforts to help children and adults with autism disorders in Canada:

April 2, 2010

As Minister of Health, I am pleased that Canada is joining other countries in recognizing April 2nd as World Autism Awareness Day. I would like to take this opportunity to thank the Autism Society of Canada and all autism organizations across the country for their tireless work in creating awareness about Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) and providing support to those affected by this condition.

ASD affects people from all walks of life, as well as their families, friends and caregivers. Roughly one out of every 150 Canadian children is affected by ASD . While there has been progress in research, care and education, we need to learn more about the causes of ASD and the most effective treatments and interventions.

The Government of Canada recognizes that autism is an important health and social issue which presents challenges for many Canadian families. We are committed to supporting research and raising awareness. The Canadian Institutes of Health Research has provided approximately $35.3 million for research related to autism since 2000. 

I would like to express my sincere appreciation to every autism organization in Canada for their continued dedication to improving the lives of Canadians living with ASD.

Leona Aglukkaq
Minister of Health
Government of Canada 

You will notice that the Government of Canada's World Autism Awareness Day message makes no reference to any  monies spent  to assist the provincial governments in providing effective evidence based preschool interventions, autism specific training of teachers and education assistants  or autism appropriate residential and treatment facilities for youths and adults.


The sum total spent by the Government of Canada to address Canada's autism crisis, "an important health and social issue which presents challenges for many Canadian families"to quote the Honourable Minister of Health, is $35.3 million dollars for research ....... over a 10 year period from 2000 to 2010.

Alexander Pope, were he with us today, might say that the Government of Canada has damned itself with faint praise,  that it has, without sneering,  taught us all to sneer  ..... at its less than feeble efforts to address Canada's important health and social issue, our national autism crisis.  

Autism in Canada - Harper Government Has Promised Little and Has Done Even Less

The following letter was sent from Autism Canada to Canadian Members of Parliament.  The Conservative Government promised very little help for autistic children and adults. Staying true to form it did not even deliver on the little that it did promise.

The  CIHR national autism symposium which Autism Canada refers to as a "consensus" symposium was declared by the CIHR  to involve consultations with the autism community. In truth the CIHR National Autism Symposium was  a sham which excluded autism advocates including me (1), (2), (3), (4), (5).

My name, as a father who had been active in advocating for autism specific  preschool and school services in New Brunswick was put forward twice by reputable autism spokespersons in New Brunswick and was rejected.  Other advocates active in seeking government funded evidence based interventions for autistic children were also excluded. Meanwhile well known anti-ABA, anti-autism cure figures were invited to attend.

Autism Canada is understandably diplomatic in dealing with an arrogant government that simply prorogues, "suspends", the operation of our federal Parliament when it suits its purposes to do so.  The reality though is that the Harper government has promised little and done less to help autistic children and adults. Meanwhile autistic children who could have been helped have languished without treatment across Canada.  That is Autism Reality in Harper's Canada.

Where I disagree with Autism Canada is in its call for a national autism division within Public Health Canada. Such an organization would amount to just another government department that would twiddle its thumbs, agonize endlessly over autism and do nothing to help autistic children and adults. We already know what has to be done.

Parents across Canada have advocated tirelessly for government funded autism intervention for their children at the preschool and school levels. The federal government could have acted by cooperating with provincial governments most of whom badly need funding for autism interventions. There is also a pressing need for more funds to provide for adult care facilities across Canada. Establishing a separate autism department will only create further delay and result in bureaucratic autism kings who will still refuse to listen to parents seeking to help their autistic children just as the CIHR and the Government of Canada have done for so long.

Autism Canada is trying diplomacy ... again.  Hopefully it will have some tiny impact on Canada's ProRogue Prime Minister.  Regardless, I thank Autism Canada for trying.

The Autism Canada letter follows:


As a Canadian Charitable Autism Organization and member of the Canadian ASD (Autism Spectrum Disorder) Alliance, Autism Canada Foundation feels a great responsibility to ensure the disorder is properly cared for across our country.  Our organization is requesting the implementation of a division for autism within the Public Health Agency of Canada (PHAC) responsible for surveillance, epidemiology and policy, specifically a National Autism Strategy.  


This would not be unlike the way in which other disorders are currently addressed within PHAC.  
While we appreciate the Honourable Lawrence Cannon’s response and the numerous federal initiatives catalogued therein, we believe these programs fall short of truly addressing the issues of concern to the millions of Canadians affected by autism.  In examining the government’s initiatives to date, we still have no national surveillance of autism or national autism strategy implemented.  Our concerns are:  
  • The $1M over five years for a National Chair in Autism Research and Interventions at Simon Fraser University has not been fulfilled.  Unfortunately, these funds were not sufficient to attract candidates for the position.
  • The $50K to translate the Canadian Autism Intervention Research Network website plus the additional $75K to enhance content is positive, but fails to inform parents on what they can do to help their children now.
  • While $27.1M has been spent on autism-related research since 2000, we need this figure to increase dramatically and for funds to be directed to autism-specific research that will have the broadest impact and follow clues provided by treatments currently working in children.
  • The Canadian Institute of Health Research national symposium was an invitation-only consensus meeting that had little or no impact on Canadians with an ASD.
  • While PHAC has consulted the autism community on ASD surveillance and is expanding Queens University’s surveillance system, we are still without a national autism surveillance system within our public health structure.    
We recognize the reasoning behind the research and initiatives that have taken place to date.  In fact, we applaud and support many of the steps that have been taken thus far.  However, the measures that have been implemented to this point are simply the first steps to tackle a major national issue.  Our concern is that the seriousness with which government officials claim to be approaching the matter is being undermined by the relatively minimal measures that have been employed to date.    


The importance of creating a division for autism within PHAC, which would facilitate the establishment of National Surveillance and a National Autism Strategy, is twofold:  
  • It would create a position of accountability and responsibility for overseeing the disease, which currently affects 1 in 150 children (United States Center for Disease Control).
  • It would give the nation a better understanding of the magnitude of the crisis we are facing so that strategic planning and appropriate interventions may be implemented.    
Our organization works hard to affect change and support families in the autism community, but the struggle to acknowledge and manage the pervasiveness of ASD nationwide must begin at the federal level.  With the return of Parliament, we implore you to reconsider the seriousness of the ASD epidemic that is afflicting millions of Canadians.  The incidence of ASD has been increasing in the United States and there is no reason to suspect it is any different in Canada.  The key to combating the disease and suppressing its exponential growth is to take swift and substantial action as outlined above.  


Autism Canada’s goal is to educate so that we might make the best decisions for all Canadians.  We look forward to working collaboratively with the Canadian ASD Alliance and the Public Health Agency of Canada to initiate a process of facing this important health issue.  
Sincerely,

Cynthia Zahoruk
President
Autism Canada





Bookmark and Share

This Autism Dad Will Not Be Voting Conservative or Green

I will not be voting Conservative in this election. Nor will I be voting Green.

As the father of a son with Autistic Disorder, assessed with profound developmental delays, I am heavily influenced by party autism platforms and histories. The Conservative Party of Stephen Harper has made clear on many occasions that, while it governs, there will be no meaningful attempt by the federal government to assist autistic children and adults or their families. That position has also been made crystal clear by the responses of Conservative candidates to questions from the Medicare for Autism Now Society.

Some Green Party candidates have been positive, and some negative, in response to the MFANS question: "If you are elected to the House of Commons on Oct. 14th, will you publicly commit to supporting legislation which will amend the Canada Health Act to include autism treatment?"

The Green Party has responded to an email from Autism Canada about creating a new federal autism bureaucracy by stating that it does not have a specific position on autism at this time. The Green Party answer, perhaps because of Autism Canada's focus on bureaucracy building, reflects the possibility of future Green Party support for an autism bureaucracy but shows no awareness of the need to provide targeted federal funding to ensure that all autistic children in Canada receive evidence based, effective ABA treatment:

On behalf of Elizabeth May, I would like to thank you for your email and for sharing with us your concerns.

While the Green Party of Canada does not have a specific policy on autism at this time, we are strongly in favour of the Department of Health furthering its mandate to include mental health, as well as developmental health, such as autism. Similarly, we would be committed to expanding the mandate of the Public Health Agency of Canada to include studies on developmental and mental health.

I asked Elizabeth May and the Green Party the following question on September 22, 2008:

Shawn Murphy, the Liberal MP for Charlottetown introduced a private members motion Bill C-304 which called for a National Autism Strategy that included an amendment to the Canada Health Act to require provincial funding of ABA treatment for autism. The motion was defeated on a second reading vote by the combined opposition of the Conservative and Bloc Quebecois parties. The Liberal and NDP party members almost all voted in favour of the motion.

Ms May will the Green Party of
Canada follow up on the Shawn Muphy autism motion by also seeking amendment of the Canada Health Act to require ABA treatment for autism?

I received no reply to my question. Autistic children in Canada do not need another federal bureaucracy to study autism and"better inform Canadians as promoted by Autism Canada. The Green Party of Canada, with no specific autism platform at present, has shown interest in Autism Canada style bureaucracy building but no interest in actually taking real action to help autistic children in Canada receive effective treatment wherever they live.

The Green Party, like the Conservative Party, will not be receiving this autism dad's vote in this election.

Senator Jim MunsonTables Bill To Recognize World Autism Awareness Day



SENATOR JIM MUNSON TABLES BILL TO RECOGNIZE WORLD AUTISM AWARENESS DAY

OTTAWA, June 10, 2008 – The Honourable Jim Munson, Senator ( Ottawa – Rideau Canal ), today introduced a bill to recognize April 2 as World Autism Awareness Day. By recognizing World Autism Awareness Day, Canada will join 192 other United Nations members who agreed that such a day would bring autism, a neurological disorder that affects an increasing number of families around the world, to the attention of all.

“By recognizing World Autism Awareness Day we are saying to families with autism: You are not alone. We care,” said Senator Munson. Autism affects one in 165 Canadian families and there is no known cure. The number of Canadians diagnosed with autism has grown by 150% in the last six years and there is no national strategy to address the growing problem. “World Autism Awareness Day will draw the attention of citizens to the plight of the many families, in Canada and around the world, who are affected by autism,” said Senator Donald Oliver, seconder of the bill. Worldwide, autism affects more children than pediatric cancer, diabetes, and AIDS combined.

For more information, please contact: The Honourable Jim Munson
Senator ( Ottawa – Rideau Canal )
Tel: (613) 947-2504

The Honourable Donald Oliver
Senator ( Nova Scotia )
Tel: (613) 943-1445

LE SÉNATEUR JIM MUNSON DÉPOSE UN PROJET DE LOI VISANT À RECONNAÎTRE LA JOURNÉE MONDIALE DE SENSIBILISATION À L’AUTISME

OTTAWA, le 10 juin 2008 – Aujourd’hui, l'honorable sénateur Jim Munson (Ottawa / Canal Rideau) a déposé un projet de loi visant à faire reconnaître le 2 avril comme la Journée mondiale de sensibilisation à l'autisme. En reconnaissant cette journée, le Canada se joindra aux 192 autres membres des Nations Unies qui ont accepté de faire que cette journée attire l’attention de tous sur l'autisme, un trouble neurologique qui continue de toucher un nombre croissant de familles de partout au monde.

« En reconnaissant la Journée mondiale de sensibilisation à l’autisme, nous disons aux familles aux prises avec l'autisme : Vous n'êtes pas seules. Nous nous préoccupons de vous », a déclaré le sénateur Munson. L'autisme, qui est incurable, est un problème pour une famille canadienne sur 165. Au cours des six dernières années, le nombre de Canadiens ayant reçu un diagnostic d'autisme a augmenté de 150 %, et il n'y a pas de stratégie nationale pour combattre ce fléau sans cesse croissant. « La Journée mondiale de sensibilisation à l’autisme attirera l'attention des citoyens sur le sort des nombreuses familles du Canada et d’ailleurs touchées par l'autisme », a affirmé le sénateur Donald Oliver, qui a appuyé le projet de loi. Dans le monde, l'autisme touche plus d'enfants que le cancer, le diabète et le sida réunis.

L’honorable Jim Munson
Sénateur (Ottawa / Canal Rideau)\
Tél. : 613-947-250

L’honorable Donald Oliver
Sénateur (Nouvelle-Écosse)
Tél. : 613-943-1445

Dr. Wendy Edwards, Pediatrician and Autism Mother, Advocates Treating Autism as a Whole Body Medical Illness

The Times Colonist has an article on yesterday's Autism Canada conference and its focus on treating autism as a whole body medical illness. Speakers included Dr. Derrick MacFabe of the UWO team which recently released its findings on proprionic acid and Dr. Martha Herbert of the Harvard Medical School. Much of the article though focused on Dr. Wendy Edwards, a Southern Ontario pediatrician whose son was diagnosed with autism at age 3. The message at the conference as summarized by the Times Colonist is that autism is a full body illness and is not limited to the brain.

Dr. Edwards advocates the use of biomedical treatments in addition to applied behaviour analysis in treating autism. She recommends diets aimed at eliminating toxins and reducing digestive tract inflammation and describes some elements of such diets including melatonin, antioxidants and the GF-CF free diet. Dr. Edwards acknowledges that her biomedical recommendations are not supported by scientific study but questions whether parents should wait while the studies are done:

"Why not do what we feel is working while we wait for the study to prove or disprove it? If we're not out there doing all these things and telling the researchers 'What about this?' the research won't get done."

There are good arguments against the use of experimental treatments for autism or any other medical condition. Financial resources are not unlimited, special diets can often add expense to a family budget already stretched tight particularly if the family is already strapped by the expense of paying for ABA, which although not curing autism, is an evidence based effective health and education intervention. Experimental treatments can also waste time and morale both of which are valuable to a family trying to help their child. Further, some seemingly innocuous interventions might in fact have unforeseen and possibly harmful effects on a child.

Still, if a family can afford the interventions, consults with physicians and does not get their hopes too high, it is difficult to see why they shouldn't try interventions backed by anecdotal evidence of other parents some of whom like Dr. Edwards are also pediatricians themselves. Especially if they do not forgo evidence based interventions in order to try experimental approaches. The UWO Proprionic Acid study grew out of parental observations. Although all parents are not also medical professionals like Dr. Edwards, they are the front line observers of their children's condition.

Autism: A Medical Condition

An autism conference featuring doctors and researchers organized by Autism Canada and featuring Dr. Martha Herbert, Dr. Derrick MacFabe and Dr. Wendy Edwards will take place this Saturday at the University of Ottawa. As the title indicates the focus will be on autism as a medical condition. Gord McDougall at 580 CFRA has commented that "governments have been reluctant to tie autism to health issues, because that would commit them to spending money from the already stretched health envelope." Mr. McDougall's comment is absolutely right.

8 years ago the lead Minister on autism issues being examined by a government of New Brunswick InterDepartmental Committee on Autism Services was the Health Minister. When funding for autism specific services was first announced it was by the Health Minister. Then the programs and leadership on the autism portfolio were transferred to the Department of Family and Community Services. The Province of New Brunswick, like other governments, did not want to acknowledge that autism interventions, particularly Applied Behaviour Analysis sought by so many parents of autistic children, were health care treatments. Autism interventions were characterized as family services to avoid having them characterized as health care treatments and reduce the possibility that a court might order them to be funded under Canada's medicare scheme. As it turned out they needn't have worried. The Auton decision was such that, medical treatment or not, Provinces would not be obligated to fund them under Medicare.

The conference this weekend will focus on autism as a medical condition, biomedical treatments , " the shift in autism paradigm to a whole-body systems approach" and current research.
The Autism Canada web site sets out the full particulars, invites registration on their web site and identifies their target audience as parents, agencies, school personnel, medical professionals, basic research scientists and others dedicated to improving the quality of life for those with ASD.

Labels

أحدث المواضيع

 
Support : Creating Website | Johny Template | Mas Template
Copyright © 2013. Entries General - All Rights Reserved
Template Created by Creating Website Published by Mas Template
Proudly powered by Blogger